Recent case law | Delivery messengers, couriers…employees? The Supreme Court says yes !
Published on :
09/01/2019
09
January
Jan
01
2019
The French Supreme Court recently handed down a very important decision for the rights of many workers in the web 2.0 economy. For the first time it has ruled on the qualification of the contract linking a delivery worker to a digital platform: is the worker self-employed or an employee bound by an employment contract? The burden of social charges and reporting are significantly higher for companies in the second case.
The Court recalls its classic case law: the subordinate relationship is characterized by the performance of work under the authority of an employer who has the power to issue orders and directives, to supervise the execution and to punish the failings of the subordinate.
In the case at hand, French judges considered that the courier is bound by an employment contract to the company using a web platform to the extent that the application was equipped with a geolocation system allowing the real-time monitoring by the company of the position of the courier and the counting of the total number of kilometers traveled. Moreover, they noted that the company had a disciplinary authority with regard to the courier, as it could issue penalties against them.
These elements characterize the existence of a relationship of subordination between the deliveryman and the digital platform.
This decision could very probably lead to further litigation for companies operating on similar platforms, resulting in the re-characterization of their relationships into employment contracts.
Employers, take note!
History
-
Recent case law | Delivering a copy of the mutually agreed termination to the employee
Published on : 06/11/2019 06 November Nov 11 2019Newsletter / Recent Case LawAt the time of the signature of the agreement of a mutually agreed terminati...
-
The saga of the Macron dismissal indemnification scale continues : a court of appeal admits that it is possible to rule out the application of the scale when an application of the ceiling would result in a disproportionate infringement of the employee’s r
Published on : 17/10/2019 17 October Oct 10 2019Newsletter / Recent Case LawOne of the Macron Orders of September 2017 established a compensation scale i...
-
Any employee exposed to a harmful or toxic substance may, under certain conditions, seek compensation from his employer, due to the obligation to ensure the safety of employees
Published on : 16/10/2019 16 October Oct 10 2019NewsNewsletter / Recent Case LawUnder French law, the “anxiety damage” helps to indemnify the situation of pe...
-
Recent case law | Challenges to the Mandatory Indemnity Scale for Unfair Dismissals
Published on : 29/07/2019 29 July Jul 07 2019NewsNewsletter / Recent Case LawOne of the Macron ordinances of September 2017 set up a compensation scheme i...
-
Recent case law | Equal treatment and company collective agreements
Published on : 25/04/2019 25 April Apr 04 2019NewsNewsletter / Recent Case LawOn April 3, 2019 the French Supreme court (Cour de cassation) put a halt on i...
-
Recent case law | Use of Geolocation tools to monitor working time
Published on : 25/04/2019 25 April Apr 04 2019NewsNewsletter / Recent Case LawIt happens quite often that companies put in place a geolocation system to mo...
-
Recent case law | Dismissal during the suspension of the contract due to work-related accident
Published on : 25/04/2019 25 April Apr 04 2019NewsNewsletter / Recent Case LawAccording to the labor code, during the time of the absence due to an industr...
-
When a settlement agreement is drafted in general terms, its scope is not limited to the sole original point of contention. The employee may not claim at a later stage for indemnification of potential rights.
Published on : 18/03/2019 18 March Mar 03 2019NewsNewsletter / Recent Case LawSometimes, upon the termination of the contract, the employer and the employe...
-
Recent Case Law | Macron dismissal indemnity grid is not valid, according to certain French labour courts
Published on : 21/01/2019 21 January Jan 01 2019NewsNewsletter / Recent Case LawA few French courts have considered that the Marcon dismissal indemnity grid...
-
Recent case law | Delivery messengers, couriers…employees? The Supreme Court says yes !
Published on : 09/01/2019 09 January Jan 01 2019NewsNewsletter / Recent Case LawThe French Supreme Court recently handed down a very important decision for t...