The principle of equality does not prevent employers from giving a 13th month bonus exclusively to executives
Company agreements may provide that special benefits are reserved for certain categories of employees, such as executives. This difference in treatment between the executive and the non-executive had so far been presumed justified, in the light of the principle of equal treatment, when they were rooted in a collective agreement. On the other hand, when they result from an employer’s decision, the company must be able to justify that the difference of treatment is based on an objective reason. The judge controls the reality and the relevance of this reason.
However, the French Supreme Court (Cour de Cassation) has just made it clear that the fact of reserving such a bonus to executives of the company is not contrary to the principle of equal treatment. This solution results from the very purpose of the 13th month bonus, which contributes to the annual remuneration paid, in the same way as the basic salary, in exchange for the employee’s work. However, executives and non-executives are not placed in an identical situation with regard to the work performed.
History
-
Successions of fixed-term contracts : be cautious of the waiting period between each contract
Published on : 04/12/2018 04 December Dec 12 2018NewsNewsletter / Recent Case LawUnder penalty of re-characterization of the fixed-term contract (CDD) as an i...
-
Recent case law | Non-Compete Clauses in Groups: A surprising decision from the Supreme Court
Published on : 19/10/2018 19 October Oct 10 2018Newsletter / Recent Case LawA recent ruling from the French supreme court has brought some clarification...
-
The principle of equality does not prevent employers from giving a 13th month bonus exclusively to executives
Published on : 15/10/2018 15 October Oct 10 2018NewsNewsletter / Recent Case LawCompany agreements may provide that special benefits are reserved for certain...