Recent case law: The Amazon Covid19 Health Case
Published on :
26/05/2020
26
May
May
05
2020
The Versailles Court of Appeal confirmed that Amazon must limit its activities pending a risk assessment with the works council- On April 24, 2020, the Versailles Court of Appeal confirmed the order of the Nanterre court of April 14, 2020, in that it ordered Amazon France to carry out, with the participation of employee representatives, an assessment of the occupational risks inherent in the Covid-19 epidemic at all of its warehouses and the implementation of the resulting safety and health protection measures. The judges of the court of appeals ordered the company to restrict its warehouses to operations relating to essential product categories listed by the company.
The context resulted from alerts for serious and imminent danger triggered by the staff representatives and withdrawal right used by some employees. Several company’s sites received letters of formal notice from the French Administration (Direccte) in order to implement Covid-19 risk prevention measures. Moreover, there was a criminal complaint issued by some employees against Amazon Logistique for Endangerment (« endangering the lives of others »)
What was the court ruling?
The lower court and the appellate court both found that Amazon had breached the employer’s general safety obligation:
-
- no sufficient risks assessment
- no implementation of the necessary protection measures
- No upstream discussion with the staff representatives on the protection measures to be implemented
However, the Appellate court ruled that the list of authorized activities is broader (i.e. high-tech and stationery goods, products for animals, hygiene, medical and food products).
The financial penalty is less severe than before the lower court: (€100,000 for each reception, preparation and/or dispatch of unauthorized products)
This decision has been seen as signaling a reminder to all employers of the legal liability that they bear in regard to the health and safety of their employees.
Businesses should keep this in mind as they restart their operations.
History
-
Prohibiting alcohol | Post-termination non-competition clause
Published on : 01/04/2022 01 April Apr 04 2022Newsletter / Recent Case Law1) Prohibiting alcohol Internal regulations (so called “réglement intérie...
-
A settlement agreement following an employee’s report of sexual harassment is invalid / Paid leave: who bears the burden of proof?
Published on : 31/12/2021 31 December Dec 12 2021Newsletter / Recent Case LawA settlement agreement following an employee’s report of sexual harassment is...
-
Employers must react when alerted to threats to employee’s safety. Failure constitutes an inexcusable fault
Published on : 30/09/2021 30 September Sep 09 2021Newsletter / Recent Case LawIn case of an accident at work (or an occupational disease), the employer com...
-
In brief: The Islamic Veil cannot be banned without a neutrality clause, even for commercial reasons
Published on : 01/07/2021 01 July Jul 07 2021NewsNewsletter / Recent Case LawIn 2017, the French Supreme court recognized the possibility, expressed in ar...
-
False accusations of discrimination justify a disciplinary dismissal
Published on : 02/04/2021 02 April Apr 04 2021NewsNewsletter / Recent Case LawAn employee who denounces or reports acts of discrimination benefits from dis...
-
Does a new Supreme Court decision allow partially illicit evidence to be submitted?
Published on : 19/01/2021 19 January Jan 01 2021NewsNewsletter / Recent Case LawA recent decision of the French Supreme Court of 25 November 2020 creates a s...
-
This month recent case laws
Published on : 02/10/2020 02 October Oct 10 2020NewsNewsletter / Recent Case LawTransfers of undertakings to more than one business A recent surprising dec...
-
Recent case law: The Amazon Covid19 Health Case
Published on : 26/05/2020 26 May May 05 2020NewsNewsletter / Recent Case LawThe Versailles Court of Appeal confirmed that Amazon must limit its activitie...
-
News Flash Covid-19 and Business: French Court orders Amazon to limit activity to essential needs
Published on : 21/04/2020 21 April Apr 04 2020NewsNewsletter / Recent Case LawCoronavirusIn two recent court cases that are important for all employers, the French co...
-
Recent case law | Employment Guarantees in CBA’s
Published on : 12/02/2020 12 February Feb 02 2020Newsletter / Recent Case LawIn a recent case, the French Supreme Court had to rule on the scope of applic...